Running low on barley malt syrup? Here are the best verified substitutes, including how to adjust your measurements.

About barley malt syrup
Barley malt syrup is a thick, dark, sticky sweetener made from sprouted barley grains that have been dried, ground, and cooked down into a concentrated liquid. It has a distinctive robust, slightly bitter, earthy flavour reminiscent of molasses, with only about half the sweetness of regular sugar. It is widely used in bread baking — particularly bagels and rye breads — to add depth of flavour, promote browning, and provide a subtle malty complexity.
Best substitute
Brown rice syrup is the closest match in terms of flavour profile, viscosity, and mild sweetness, making it an excellent swap in bread and bagel recipes. It lacks the distinctive malt flavour but performs almost identically in texture and colour.
Alternative
Molasses shares a similar dark colour, thick consistency, and robust bittersweet flavour that makes it a practical substitute in breads and savoury baking. It is significantly more intensely flavoured and slightly more bitter, so use a smaller amount blended with a neutral sweetener like honey or golden syrup to balance it out.
| Country | Name |
|---|---|
| Australia | barley malt syrup |
| Canada | barley malt syrup |
| New Zealand | barley malt syrup |
| United Kingdom | malt extract |
| United States | barley malt syrup |
Alternative
Honey works as a straightforward one-for-one substitute in most bread and bagel recipes, providing the necessary sugars for yeast activity and a degree of browning. It lacks the malty bitterness and is considerably sweeter, so the final flavour will be noticeably different, though the texture will be similar.
Alternative
Golden syrup is a widely available Australian and British alternative that provides a similar thick consistency and mild caramel sweetness. It is lighter in colour and flavour than barley malt syrup and lacks any malt character, but it performs well in baking applications where the malt flavour is secondary.
Alternative
Dried malt extract powder is a dehydrated form of malt syrup and delivers a very authentic malt flavour. It must be dissolved in warm water before use to approximate the syrup form, making it best suited for bread and bagel doughs rather than glazes.